If you’re looking to buy a new car, you’ve got a few options to try and break down.
Manual vs Automatic
Services
Manual cars are cheaper to service, due to their older parts. Automatic cars are quickly closing the gap, however, that this is already negligible, and will long term not be an issue.
Winner: tie.
Fuel
In the past, it was pretty much a given that manual cars were a lot more fuel efficient than automatic cars.
Nowadays, automatic cars have more gears than before, and even more than manual cars in recent times, which all means that automatic cars are just as fuel efficient as manual cars, and are even sometimes outstripping them in this field.
Winner: tie.
Initial Cost
Manual cars are often cheaper than their automatic counterparts, but there are more and more cases of them being sold at the same prices.
Winner: Manual.
Repairs
The cost of repairing manual and automatic transmission is a big difference. A complete rebuild of a manual transmission might cost between $600 and $1500. The equivalent repair costs for an automatic can run between $3,000 to $10,000 to rebuild the entire clutch system.
Winner: Manual.
Hybrid vs non-Hybrid
Services
There is the myth that hybrids are more expensive to service than non-hybrids, and it’s exactly that – a myth. Generally, the first 5 years (and more) of a hybrid is comparable in service to other cars with regards to cost.
Hybrids can generally save on the costs of brake pads, as they have regenerative braking systems to minimise the wear on the brake pads and extend their life.
Winner: Hybrid.
Initial Cost
The initial cost of a hybrid car will, at least in the short term, exceed the cost of non-hybrid. You’ll need to balance this against the individual car’s cost and it’s fuel efficiency to see how quickly it will pay for itself. The general rule of thumb is a hybrid car should be covering the cost of the difference in 5 years of fuel saving.
Winner: Non-Hybrid.
Fuel
The main attraction of a hybrid is the savings on fuel. Hybrid cars can boast over 20 kilometres per litre. These numbers are largely based on city driving. Take the hybrid out for highway driving, and it quickly loses it’s edge.
Winner: Hybrid
Insurance
Some insurers have lower premiums for hybrid cars, so factor in the costs of insurance. Get some quotes from insurers to factor in the potential savings.
Winner: tie
Repairs
Hybrid critics are quick to jump on claims that Hybrids are more expensive to repair. However, hybrid dealers generally have very long warranty periods. Battery packs are actually doing better in real world situations than expected, and the prices for replacements batteries are continually decreasing.
Winner: Hybrid
At the end of the day, you need to do some hard math. Calculating the fuel savings for hybrid vs non-hybrid is the biggest decision you’ll have to make, and seeing how quickly it outstrips the initial investment.





